What should Henry Choose?

posted by Sifat
- January 28 2011 01:32:09 AM

Henry has been caught stealing cattle, and is brought into town for justice. The judge is his ex-wife Gretchen, who wants to show him some sympathy, but the law clearly calls for two shots to be taken at Henry from close range. To make things a little better for Henry, Gretchen tells him she will place two bullets into a six-chambered revolver in successive order. She will spin the chamber, close it, and take one shot. If Henry is still alive, she will then either take another shot, or spin the chamber again before shooting.

Henry is a bit incredulous that his own ex-wife would carry out the punishment, and a bit sad that she was always such a rule follower. He steels himself as Gretchen loads the chambers, spins the revolver, and pulls the trigger. Whew! It was blank. Then Gretchen asks, "Do you want me to pull the trigger again, or should I spin the chamber a second time before pulling the trigger?"

What should Henry choose?

Henry is a bit incredulous that his own ex-wife would carry out the punishment, and a bit sad that she was always such a rule follower. He steels himself as Gretchen loads the chambers, spins the revolver, and pulls the trigger. Whew! It was blank. Then Gretchen asks, "Do you want me to pull the trigger again, or should I spin the chamber a second time before pulling the trigger?"

What should Henry choose?

Reply by Sifat
- January 28 2011 01:32:42 AM

Hint- Weigh all the possibilities and pick the most likely outcome.

Reply by Caprico
- January 28 2011 03:47:37 AM

He should choose to spin it again.

The probability of the shot being blank was 4 out of 6. The probability of it being a blank just before the bullet is 1 out of 4. Thus it being one of the other three blanks is 3/6, which is half. Carry on the logic, and you shall arrive at the conclusion that he should spin it again. Am I right? (I'm too tired to type the entire answer out...

The probability of the shot being blank was 4 out of 6. The probability of it being a blank just before the bullet is 1 out of 4. Thus it being one of the other three blanks is 3/6, which is half. Carry on the logic, and you shall arrive at the conclusion that he should spin it again. Am I right? (I'm too tired to type the entire answer out...

Reply by Caprico
- January 28 2011 03:48:26 AM

Sorry, i messed. he shouldn't spin the barrel. Sorry sorry sorry....

Reply by Sifat
- January 28 2011 03:53:57 AM

Henry should have Gretchen pull the trigger again without spinning.

We know that the first chamber Gretchen fired was one of the four empty chambers. Since the bullets were placed in consecutive order, one of the empty chambers is followed by a bullet, and the other three empty chambers are followed by another empty chamber. So if Henry has Gretchen pull the trigger again, the probability that a bullet will be fired is 1/4.

If Gretchen spins the chamber again, the probability that she shoots Henry would be 2/6, or 1/3, since there are two possible bullets that would be in firing position out of the six possible chambers that would be in position.

That was my answer which i submitted. So.... almost, but almost it's fairly Right. I gave the whole answer because of your nice answer.

We know that the first chamber Gretchen fired was one of the four empty chambers. Since the bullets were placed in consecutive order, one of the empty chambers is followed by a bullet, and the other three empty chambers are followed by another empty chamber. So if Henry has Gretchen pull the trigger again, the probability that a bullet will be fired is 1/4.

If Gretchen spins the chamber again, the probability that she shoots Henry would be 2/6, or 1/3, since there are two possible bullets that would be in firing position out of the six possible chambers that would be in position.

That was my answer which i submitted. So.... almost, but almost it's fairly Right. I gave the whole answer because of your nice answer.

Reply by Sifat
- January 28 2011 03:55:14 AM

Please do try and think about my latest published big riddles as they really are somewhat tricky(according to me)

Reply by TannerG
- February 26 2011 08:46:47 PM

This is identical to the Russian Roulette Choice riddle on this website.

To post a response, simply log in with your Google Account.